Wimbledon and Sutton Railway

The Wimbledon and Sutton Railway (W&SR) was a railway company established by an Act of Parliament in 1910 to build a railway line in Surrey (now south-west London) from Wimbledon to Sutton via Merton and Morden in the United Kingdom. The railway was promoted by local landowners hoping to increase the value of their land through its development for housing. It was initially planned that services on the railway would be operated by the London Underground's Metropolitan District Railway (MDR) by an extension of its existing service from Wimbledon.

Delays in finding the funding, opposition from the two mainline companies that the line was intended to connect, and World War I, led to the start of construction work being delayed until 1927. The line was completed and opened in January 1930, although the planned extension of the MDR was not implemented and the service was provided by the Southern Railway. The opening of the line stimulated residential development as planned, but competition from the London Underground's City and South London Railway, which had its terminus at Morden, meant that the line did not achieve the hoped for passenger numbers.

Background
During the second half of the 19th century, the Surrey villages of Wimbledon and Sutton experienced rapid residential growth stimulated by the railways running through their areas, with landowners in both areas profiting from the development of new suburban housing on their previously rural estates. Less accessible to the railways, the parishes of Merton and Morden which lay between Wimbledon and Sutton remained largely rural, and, starting in the 1880s, a series of railway schemes were proposed to bring a new line through the area and increase the value of the land.

Unsuccessful private bills were presented to Parliament in 1884, 1888, 1890 and 1891 seeking permission to construct a new railway between the London and South Western Railway's (L&SWR's) line through Wimbledon station to the north and the London, Brighton and South Coast Railway's (LB&SCR's) Sutton station in the south.

Establishment
On 7 October 1908, engineer H. D. Searles-Wood and Sir George Smallman organised a meeting to consider a new plan for a Wimbledon to Sutton railway, and a committee was formed to promote the plan. A further meeting, held in 1909, included landowner William Innes, nephew of John Innes, the developer of Merton Park. It was estimated that £350,000 (approximately £ today) of capital was required, only part of which was to be provided by the promoters. Some of the remainder was sought from the MDR (now the London Underground's District line) which the promoters hoped would operate the service over the line by extending its service from Wimbledon. On 16 November 1909, notice of the intention to bring a private bill before Parliament was published.

The bill proposed a 5.5 mi line with ten stations to be operated by electric trains which would provide a service taking 32 minutes to reach Waterloo from Sutton. The LB&SCR opposed the line on the grounds that it would compete with its own services from Sutton to central London, and claimed that its own planned electrification of its lines to Victoria and London Bridge would offer quicker journeys than the W&SR route.The LB&SCR also believed that a connection for the W&SR would give the MDR service the chance to extend its service to Epsom and beyond. The L&SWR had concerns that its tracks from Putney to Wimbledon, over which the MDR provided the service, were already at capacity and could not cope with the extended MDR service to Sutton.

Nonetheless, the Wimbledon and Sutton Railway Act, 1910 received Royal Assent on 26 July 1910. The act approved the railway and allowed for the L&SWR connection at Wimbledon but did not allow for a connection to the LB&SCR at Sutton; instead the W&SR was to build a separate station with a pedestrian connection to the LB&SCR's station. Intermediate stations were approved for Elm Grove in Wimbledon, adjacent to the All England Lawn Tennis and Croquet Club's original grounds, Cannon Hill, Merton Park, Morden, Elm Farm, Sutton Common, Collingwood Road and Cheam. Power for the line was to be supplied by the Underground Electric Railways Company of London (UERL), owner of the MDR, from its Lots Road Power Station.

Delays
From the beginning, the company encountered delays in implementing its plans. Neither of the two main line railway companies were interested in investing in the line, so the W&SR's promoters approached the MDR for assistance. In 1911, Albert Stanley, managing director of the MDR, agreed that it would finance the construction if the promoters would guarantee a return of £6,000 per year for ten years. The MDR was to cover any shortfall below 4.5 per cent return on capital. To provide additional capacity for Sutton trains on the MDR's Wimbledon branch, the MDR published a bill on 21 November 1911 seeking permission to construct additional tracks on the L&SWR owned section from Wimbledon to East Putney. The works were approved by the Metropolitan District Railway Act, 1912, which received assent on 7 August 1912. The L&SWR was to build the additional tracks with the MDR covering the cost.

On 22 November 1912, both the W&SR and the MDR published notices that further bills would be submitted to extend the time limit imposed by the 1910 Act for the compulsory purchase of the land needed for the railway, to enable the W&SR to raise additional capital, and to give the MDR powers to take over the W&SR. The MDR bill contained provisions to increase the capacity on the MDR owned section of the Wimbledon branch by constructing further additional tracks from south of Parsons Green to south of Walham Green station (now Fulham Broadway). The requested extension of time and other powers were granted by the Wimbledon and Sutton Railway Act, 1913, given Royal Assent on 15 August 1913. In December 1912, the original promoters were replaced on the W&SR board by UERL nominees and the shares in the company were transferred to the UERL or its shareholders. In late 1913, changes were made to the track layout at Wimbledon station, including a new platform for use by the W&SR line trains, and land for the junctions with the L&SWR mainline was purchased.

On 16 November 1914, after the outbreak of war, the MDR gave notice of another bill which sought a further extension of time for land purchases. The MDR was also to stand guarantor for the W&SR and to lease the W&SR's undertakings, in effect taking over the W&SR. This was granted under the Metropolitan District Railway Act, 1915 on 24 June 1915. War-time restrictions prevented any construction and so extensions to the earlier acts were granted each year from 1918 to 1922 to give a final date of 26 July 1924 for completion of the compulsory purchase.

Revised plans
In November 1922, notices of new bills to be placed before Parliament were published by the W&SR, by the LER, and by one of its subsidiary companies, the City and South London Railway (C&SLR), which is now part of the London Underground's Northern line. Taken together, the bills brought significant changes to the plans for the Wimbledon to Sutton line. The C&SLR was an underground railway running in deep tunnels. In 1922 its line ran from Euston to Clapham Common. The C&SLR proposed to extend it for "6 miles, 1 furlong and 7.2 chains" (6.215 mi) from Clapham Common through Balham, Tooting, Merton and Morden to connect to the route of the W&SR and then continue to Sutton. The LER, C&SLR, and MDR would invest in the construction of the W&SR, for which the estimated cost had risen to £1.7 million (approximately £ today). The MDR would operate trains over the W&SR from Sutton to Wimbledon and thence to central London; the C&SLR would operate trains over the southern end of the W&SR from Sutton to Morden then via the new C&SLR extension to Clapham Common and northwards. The plans also included the construction of a depot at Morden for use by MDR and C&SLR trains.

The Southern Railway (SR), successor to both the L&SWR and the LB&SCR under the 1923 grouping of railways, objected to the plan to extend the C&SLR line to Sutton – Sir Herbert Walker, General Manager of the SR, described the proposals as an "invasion" of the SR's territory allocated by the grouping agreement. Walker proposed a limited extension of the CS&LR as far as Tooting and offered to allow the C&SLR's tube trains to run to Wimbledon via a connection to the SR's Tooting to Wimbledon line. He also proposed that the SR should build the W&SR instead. The UERL rejected Walker's plan, claiming that the entire extension to Morden was needed as that was the only place to build the necessary depot. Without the compromise arrangement, the House of Lords rejected the whole scheme but the House of Commons, which wanted the tube service to be extended from Clapham, encouraged further negotiations between the UERL and SR.

In July 1923, an agreement was made that the SR would withdraw its objection in exchange for a transfer of the UERL's interests in the W&SR. The District railway would be allowed to operate to Sutton via the W&SR route, although this was not pursued further. The Wimbledon and Sutton Railway Act, 1923, the London Electric Railway Act, 1923 and the City and South London Railway Act, 1923 all received Royal Assent on 2 August 1923. The SR arranged for the take-over and winding-up of the W&SR.

The C&SLR soon started construction of its southern extension which opened to a terminus at Morden on 13 September 1926, with a depot south of the station and within 200 yd of the W&SR route, although no connection was made between the two lines. Without the extension of the District line to Sutton, the additional tracks between Wimbledon and Putney were not required and the work was not carried out. The additional tracks between Parsons Green and Fulham Broadway were constructed but have only been used as sidings. Once the tube line was opened, the Underground company established a network of bus routes to the south, using Morden station as their hub. These routes had a significant impact on the SR's operations in the area, with the SR estimating in 1928 that it had lost approximately four million passengers per year. The UERL though was able to demonstrate that its passenger numbers on its buses to Sutton station were actually more than double those for Morden.

Construction
Construction of the line from Wimbledon to Sutton was slower. Work started at Wimbledon in October 1927, but property purchases were not completed until the middle of 1928 and the contractor, Sir Robert McAlpine & Sons, did not begin work at Sutton until July 1928. The landscape traversed by the line is undulating and rises from about 50 ft above sea-level at Wimbledon to about 200 ft at Sutton. Designed for operation exclusively by the electric multiple unit, extensive embankments and cuttings were constructed and steep gradients up to 1 in 44 (2.27%) and tight-radius curves were employed. Only 35 chains (0.438 mi) of the route was built as level track and 24 bridges were required, the largest of which spans 120 ft over the A24 close to Morden Park.

The station buildings at the two end stations, Wimbledon and Sutton, were rebuilt between 1927 and 1930 and six stations were constructed at Wimbledon Chase, South Merton, Morden South, St. Helier, Sutton Common and West Sutton. Fewer stations were built than planned in 1910, but all were on sites proposed then, except St Helier station which was built to serve the London County Council's new St. Helier housing estate, then under construction. With the exception of South Merton, which was built without, all stations had white stone or concrete faced buildings with access to the platforms by stairs up or down from street level. Provided with 520 ft long island platforms, the stations could accommodate trains eight coaches long.

Opening and operation
Work from Wimbledon to South Merton was completed quickly so that services could begin running as a single-track operation on 7 July 1929. The remainder of the line opened on 5 January 1930, more than forty-five years after the first Wimbledon to Sutton link was proposed.

As hoped by the original promoters, the opening of the line stimulated the construction of new areas of private and public residential development throughout the 1930s, although large areas remain as parks and playing fields. The St. Helier estate was completed in 1936. The opening of the Wimbledon to Sutton line and the C&SLR led the population of the parish of Morden, previously the most rural of the areas through which the lines passed, to increase from 1,355 in 1921 to 12,618 in 1931 and 35,417 in 1951.

Ordinary ticket sales from Morden South station increased from 9,840 in 1930 to 50,817 in 1938 but, from the SR's perspective, the line was not a great success. The service, originally operating from West Croydon to Holborn Viaduct station in central London, was slow and indirect and many of the potential passengers from the line's catchment area continued to use the buses and tube route via Morden.

Goods services operated on the line to a goods yard at St. Helier station until it was closed in 1963, and to an Express Dairies bottling plant adjacent to Morden South station which opened in 1954 and closed in 1992.

The line now is called the St Helier Line and forms part of the Sutton Loop, which is served by trains from First Capital Connect and Southern.